When the phone never rang, Jenkins went into a downward spiral. His confidence was shaken and not only was he doubting his place within the organization, but he also began to question whether he even had what it took to be a professional pitcher.
"I was somehow getting Red Sox hitters out, and then I turned the page and I don't think I could get my grandmother out," Jenkins said. "I kept thinking in my head, 'What do I throw, what am I doing wrong?' I tried to start mechanically fix things, and that was leading to 55-pitch sides [side sessions].
"I never felt right, something was always bothering me in my shoulder, and I guess the good lord was good enough to let me pull something else so I could sit down, take it easy and start over. When I started over, I didn't worry about mechanics, I went back to throwing the way I know how to throw."
Jenkins gradually built up arm strength and the confidence started to return when he enjoyed some success during a brief stint in the Gulf Coast League. Jenkins joked about how odd it was for a 25-year-old to find his footing in what is essentially a rookie league, but it was a necessary building block for his career.
The Tennessee native then received a promotion to Double-A New Hampshire and with that came an opportunity to rejoin a starting rotation. He tossed 15 innings over the course of four appearances while allowing just two runs and the progress created another opportunity at the big league level.
Jenkins was promoted to the Blue Jays after right-hander Brad Lincoln was optioned to the Minor Leagues, and while his role is somewhat up in the air, he's just happy to be back in the fold.
As for not getting the call, even after the Blue Jays told the media back in late May that Jenkins was only being sent down for 10 days, there are no longer any hard feelings.
"It was tough to swallow for me, but at the end of the day it was a decision that was made for the team and I had to live with it, and that's perfectly fine," Jenkins said. "I should have pitched better in Triple-A and I didn't, I have no one to blame but myself. As you can see with my Triple-A numbers, they were a little inflated (7.48 ERA).
"For me, right now, I just want to pitch and whatever gets me into the game, I'll be glad to stay there. If they want to keep me in the 'pen as the long man, I'll gladly do that. I enjoyed that last year, and if they want me to start ... every five days I'll go out there and give it everything I've got."